Disparate treatment is a discrimination that occurs when an employer treats an employee or job applicant differently because of their membership in a protected class. This type of discrimination is illegal under the Civil Rights Act and other federal and state laws.
When an employee makes a disparate treatment claim, they must show that they were treated differently than other employees who are not in the protected class. This can be difficult to prove, as it requires showing that the employer had a discriminatory intent.
However, even if an employer did not intend to discriminate, they may still be liable for disparate treatment if their actions have a disparate impact on a protected class. This type of discrimination is often unintentional, but can still be illegal.
Table of Contents
What is Disparate Treatment?
Disparate treatment is unfair treatment of an employee or group based on prejudice or discrimination. It involves unequal and unfavorable handling, typically in the form of disparate impact or disparate treatment
Sexual orientation and national origin are two examples of protected classes that are often discriminated against in the workplace. If you believe you have been the victim of disparate treatment discrimination, you should contact an experienced employment law attorney to discuss your options.
What Is a Protected Class?
A protected class is a group of people who are protected from discrimination under the law. The federal government recognizes several protected classes, including race, color, national origin, sex, religion, and disability.
State and local laws may also protect additional classes, such as sexual orientation and gender identity. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 is a federal law that prohibits discrimination in employment on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. The Act also prohibits disparate treatment discrimination against employees who are members of a protected class.
Discriminatory Practices against Protected Class
There are many different types of discriminatory practices that can occur in the workplace. Some common examples include:
- Refusing to hire or promote an employee because of their membership in a protected class
- Firing an employee because of their membership in a protected class
- Paying an employee less because of their membership in a protected class
- Segregated facilities
- Disparate impact discrimination
Examples of Disparate Treatment
There are several disparate treatment discriminatory practices that employers may engage in, including:
1. Failure to hire
An employer refuses to hire an individual because of their membership in a protected class. Disparate treatment varies from mild to severe, and it can happen in any workplace. Some examples are an employer who refuses to interview or hire qualified women for a position because they want an all-male staff or an employer who only hires white applicants for a customer-facing position.
2. Disparate compensation
An employer pays employees in the same role differently based on their membership in a protected class. For example, an employer may give two employees the same job title and responsibilities but pay one employee less because of their gender.
3. Disparate promotion
An employer promotes one employee over another because of their membership in a protected class. For example, an employer may promote a white employee over a more qualified person of color because they want a diverse management team.
4. Disparate job assignments
An employer assigns an employee to a certain job or task because of their membership in a protected class. For example, an employer may only assign women to clean jobs or men to manual labor tasks.
5. Disparate working conditions
An employer subjects an employee to different or harsher working conditions because of their membership in a protected class. For example, an employer may give pregnant employees hazardous assignments or require them to take leave without pay.
6. Harassment
An employer tolerates or encourages harassment of an employee because of their membership in a protected class. This can include anything from making offensive comments to physical assaults. For example, an employer may allow their employees to make racist jokes or use racial slurs against a co-worker.
7. Retaliation
An employer punishes an employee for complaining about disparate treatment or other forms of discrimination. For example, an employer may demote an employee who files a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC).
What are the Consequences of Disparate Treatment Discrimination?
If you are the victim of disparate treatment discrimination, you may be entitled to relief under state or federal law. The type of relief available will depend on the jurisdiction in which you live and the facts of your case.
Possible remedies for disparate treatment discrimination include:
- Reinstatement
- Promotions
- Back pay
- Front pay
- Attorneys’ fees and costs
- Compensatory damages for emotional distress
- Punitive damages
How to Prevent Disparate Treatment Discrimination
There are several things employers can do to prevent disparate treatment discrimination in the workplace, including:
- Providing equal opportunities for all employees, regardless of their membership in a protected class. This means offering the same job duties, compensation, benefits, and promotions to all employees.
- Establishing policies and procedures that prohibit disparate treatment discrimination. These policies should be well-publicized and enforced consistently.
- Educating employees about disparate treatment discrimination. Employees should be made aware of what disparate treatment discrimination is and how to prevent it. Employers should also provide a way for employees to report incidents of disparate treatment discrimination.
- Investigating complaints of disparate treatment discrimination. All complaints should be investigated promptly and thoroughly. If disparate treatment discrimination is found to have occurred, appropriate disciplinary action should be taken.
Disparate treatment vs. Disparate Impact
While disparate treatment is understood as direct discrimination while on the other hand disparate impact is characterized as indirect discrimination. Disparate treatment is intentional discrimination while disparate impact can be unintentional discrimination.
It is important to note that disparate treatment discrimination is different from disparate impact discrimination. Disparate impact discrimination occurs when an employer has a policy or practice that has a negative impact on a protected class, even if there is no intent to discriminate.
For example, an employer may have a policy of only hiring people with clean criminal records. This policy may have a disparate impact on minorities, who are more likely to have been convicted of a crime.
While disparate treatment discrimination is illegal under federal law, disparate impact discrimination is not necessarily illegal. Whether or not disparate impact discrimination is illegal will depend on the jurisdiction in which you live and the facts of your case.
If you believe you have been the victim of disparate impact discrimination, you should contact an experienced employment discrimination attorney to discuss your legal options.
Impacts of Disparate Treatment Lawsuits on a Business
Disparate treatment lawsuits can have a significant impact on a business, both financially and reputationally.
Financially, disparate treatment lawsuits can be costly to defend. If an employer is found to have engaged in disparate treatment discrimination, they may be ordered to pay damages to the victim. These damages can include back pay, front pay, reinstatement, promotion, attorneys’ fees, and costs, and compensatory damages for emotional distress. In some cases, punitive damages may also be awarded.
Reputationally, disparate treatment lawsuits can damage an employer’s reputation. If an employer is found to have engaged in disparate treatment discrimination, they may be seen as being discriminatory and unfair. This can make it difficult to attract and retain employees.
Disparate treatment lawsuits can also have a negative impact on employee morale. If employees believe that they are being treated unfairly, they may become disgruntled and less productive. Preventing disparate treatment discrimination is essential for maintaining a positive workplace and avoiding the potential impacts of a lawsuit.
How do employees prove disparate treatment discrimination?
There are a few ways that employees can prove disparate treatment discrimination. The most common way is by showing that the employer treated them differently than other employees who are not in the protected class. For example, if an employer only promotes white employees, this could be evidence of disparate treatment discrimination against employees of color.
Another way to prove disparate treatment discrimination is by showing that the employer treated the employee differently because of their membership in a protected class. For example, if an employer treats an employee differently because they are pregnant, this could be evidence of disparate treatment discrimination against pregnant employees.
If you believe you have been the victim of disparate treatment discrimination, you should contact an experienced employment discrimination attorney to discuss your legal options. An experienced attorney can help you gather evidence to support your claim and will fight for your rights.
Tips to avoid disparate treatment in an organization
Avoiding disparate treatment claims is a business necessity and organizations have to resolve disparate treatment cases and resolve workplace discrimination. Some of the tips that will help your organization to avoid disparage treatment are-
1. Policies and procedures
Establish policies and procedures that prohibit disparate treatment discrimination. These policies should be well-publicized and enforced consistently.
2. Educating employees about disparate treatment discrimination
Employees should be made aware of what disparate treatment discrimination is and how to prevent it. Employers should also provide a way for employees to report incidents of disparate treatment discrimination.
3. Investigating complaints of disparate treatment discrimination
All complaints should be investigated promptly and thoroughly. If disparate treatment discrimination is found to have occurred, appropriate disciplinary action should be taken.
4. Creating a diverse workforce
A workforce that is diverse in terms of race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, and other factors is less likely to engage in disparate treatment discrimination.
5. Monitoring hiring and promotion practices
Disparate treatment discrimination can occur at any stage of the employment process, from hiring to promotion. It is important to monitor hiring and promotion practices to ensure that disparate treatment is not occurring.
6. Creating a culture of respect
A culture of respect in the workplace will help to prevent disparate treatment discrimination. Employers should promote a culture of respect by treating all employees fairly and respectfully.
The above-mentioned tips will help your organization in avoiding disparate treatment and create a diverse and inclusive workforce.
What is the comparative disparate treatment?
Comparative disparate treatment is when an employer has a history of treating employees of certain groups. For example, if an employer only promotes white employees, this could be evidence of disparate treatment discrimination against employees of color.
What is the overt disparate treatment?
When someone makes an unfavorable decision or judgment about you on the basis of your gender, race, religion, or another personal characteristic, it’s known as overt disparate treatment. This is a case of overt disparate treatment if a manager explains to a woman that she didn’t receive a promotion because men are better leaders.
Conclusion!
On the concluding note, it is clear from the above-detailed information that disparate treatment is a form of discrimination in which an employer treats an employee differently because of their membership in a protected class.
Now, what do you think organizations can do to prevent disparate treatment discrimination? Do let us know in the comment section below.
Liked this post? Check out the complete series on Human resources
