Organizations that want to experience greater efficiency and employee happiness can leverage the Job Characteristics Model (JCM) – a structure developed by organizational psychologists that explains how certain job characteristics contribute to improved worker productivity and fulfillment.
Developed by Hackman and Oldham in 1976, with an update following in 1980 (Hackman & Oldham, 1976, 1980), the Job Characteristics Model provides invaluable insight on how to most effectively enhance jobs within organizations. When it comes to designing work, the model provides five core job characteristics that you should consider to achieve optimal results. –
- Skill variety
- Task identity,
- Task significance,
- Autonomy, and
- Feedback
Table of Contents
What is the Job Characteristics Model?
The Job Characteristics Model (JCM) theorizes that employees’ job performance is enhanced by five key characteristics. Richard Hackman and Greg Oldham initially unveiled the Job Characteristics Model (JCM) in their esteemed book “Work Redesign”.
According to the Job Characteristics Model, employees are likely to be more inspired and motivated when their job requires a lot of skill and offers interesting challenges. Conversely, tasks that are repetitive or mundane can lead to apathy among workers.
By leveraging the JCM, managers and HR professionals can significantly improve their working environment for colleagues and employees.
Through the use of JCM, employers can empower their staff to tailor their positions and turn tedious tasks into engaging ones. This not only leads to greater job satisfaction but also improves productivity while enhancing employees’ output quality.
5 Core Job Characteristics
As per job characteristics theory, there 5 core characteristics you should pay heed to
1. Skill Variety
A job involves completing a variety of tasks using different skills and abilities. The range of tasks involved in a job can vary significantly.
For instance, a customer service representative is tasked with answering phone calls and emails, troubleshooting any issues that arise, as well as providing customers with helpful feedback.
2. Task Identity
Completing a job with identifiable outcomes is an important factor in job satisfaction. Task identity refers to the degree of completion of a task and whether or not there is a clearly defined start and end point.
For instance, working as an interior designer can offer a sense of accomplishment and identity through completing each project from concept to installation.
3. Task Significance
Task significance is the degree of influence a job has on outcomes. When an employee’s work involves protecting lives, aiding people in need, or conserving the environment – these roles are intrinsically rewarding as they have a powerful and meaningful purpose. This effect can be observed in customers, throughout the organization, and beyond!
For instance, a CEO holds the potential to propel an organization into success, while an HR manager impacts the morale and culture of a workplace.
4. Autonomy
In terms of autonomy, Job Characteristics Model examines the degree to which employees have the independence to make decisions and complete tasks without supervision. Job roles that grant employees this sense of independence can be empowering and lead to greater job satisfaction. When autonomy levels are weak, feelings of micromanagement and constriction can emerge.
For instance, a medical professional may be authorized to make instantaneous decisions in urgent circumstances whereas a customer service rep might need authorization ahead of starting certain duties.
5. Feedback
Feedback refers to the degree to which a job provides an employee with knowledge of their progress in completing tasks. This information can be delivered by supervisors, clients, or peers. Job roles that offer feedback provide employees with a sense of satisfaction as they can gain an understanding of how their hard efforts are appreciated.
For example, entrepreneurs might experience a tremendous sense of pride and satisfaction when they receive positive feedback from their customers on the success of their business or product launch. Likewise, teachers often feel fulfilled by witnessing the progress made by their students.
Project Manager Example of Job Characteristics Model
- Skill variety. High. A successful project manager is one that has mastered the art of recruiting, managing virtual teams, budgeting resources, developing timelines, and communicating goals effectively.
- Task identity. Medium. A project manager coordinates numerous activities to ensure the successful completion of the overall task and its various components. They must oversee all pieces throughout the lifespan of the project, even though it is often their team that does most or all of the work. It can be challenging for them to track progress through multiple individual parts and achieve a unified end result.
- Task significance. High. Completing a successful project offers an invaluable reward to the organization or client – delivering tangible value, as well as a notable return on investment. It is vital that project managers are held responsible for achieving these results and ensuring their success.
- Autonomy. High. A project manager enjoys a great level of freedom that can be modified depending on the particular contract and agreement with the client.
- Feedback. High. Solutions that result in successful project completion are often informed by feedback from a variety of sources, including team members, clients, other key players, and supervisors. All in all, when an employee performs a job, feedback is useful in gauging the success of his or her job. This input helps inform decision-making processes for the project manager to ensure ultimate success.
What is the purpose of the job characteristics model?
Assisting in forming effective job design strategies
When your business is composed of multiple employees in diverse roles, it can be difficult to assign tasks to each position. The job characteristics model allows you to evaluate all the required functions and create a variety of jobs based on them. This approach makes organizing work easier and more efficient for everyone involved.
Improving Employee satisfaction
Human Resources and management working together through the job characteristics model can create an environment of increased job satisfaction, even if it isn’t possible to remove all uninteresting tasks. This model has proven successful in reducing such challenges.
Enriching job experience
Boost your daily work duties by infusing them with further assignments and objectives, creating a more stimulating job experience. Job enrichment is not just about making things easier – it can provide purpose to the role you do regularly! With this process, you’ll find that heading into your everyday tasks feels far more motivating than before.
Delegating tasks to the right individuals
The JCM seeks to improve job designs by breaking tasks into smaller, more manageable pieces and endowing workers with the authority and autonomy necessary for completion. By allowing employees greater control over their work environment, this model can result in higher levels of satisfaction.
Streamlining your message and organizational information
A well-planned job analysis, complete with explicit tasks and responsibilities assigned to each role, makes it much simpler for organizational management. This approach enables a clear understanding of who is responsible for which duties as well as facilitates alignment between roles and the general organization design.
How to apply the Job Characteristics Model
1. Delegate tasks
By appointing roles according to an individual’s expertise and understanding, tasks can be completed efficiently and with precision. This method of the delegation will ensure that the job is carried out both promptly and accurately. Allocating tasks to less experienced staff members who are able to finish them aids in the growth and progress of their skillset.
2. Vary the tasks
To utilize the Job Characteristics Model efficiently, one must vary the tasks included in their job. Allowing employees to undertake a variety of tasks that utilize their full range of skills, reflects the central characteristic at the basis of job enrichment. Experiencing diversity in a role can help workers find more satisfaction and pleasure in their work.
3. Assign teamwork
You can also employ the job characteristics model in your workplace by delegating team-oriented tasks. Teamwork can help you apply the Job Characteristic Model by allowing employees to see their tangible accomplishments from start to end, thus cultivating a sense of task identity. Additionally, it encourages skill variety as team members are exposed to different roles and responsibilities.
4. Complete performance evaluations
The JCM’s success largely relies on consistent feedback, and one of the best ways to provide this is through employee performance evaluations. Not only will these assessments help your staff grow and improve their work, but they also guarantee that your team receives the necessary input for continued development. When conducting performance evaluations, consider instituting a reward system to recognize your employees’ efforts and accomplishments – this could be in the form of bonuses or an employee recognition board.
5. Encourage employees to rotate jobs
To ensure that employees remain engaged and motivated, create a workplace structure where they can periodically rotate jobs. This will allow them to increase their knowledge base even further by experiencing different roles within the company.
How can you measure job characteristics?
To evaluate if jobs provide fulfillment and to examine their model, Oldham, and Hackman developed the Job Diagnostic Survey (JDS). This self-report measure has been used by employees for measuring five job characteristics as established by Hackman & Oldham in 1980.
The JDS also takes into account an employee’s Growth Need Strength, which measures how much weight they put on the chance to cultivate and advance in their job. This Model also presumes that the staff member has adequate knowledge, abilities, and skills (KSAs) for properly executing the work.
Psychological States and Work Outcomes
By exploring how to make work more agreeable and productive, the job characteristics model was developed. This model can significantly impact employees’ mental well-being by influencing different psychological states (or job characteristics model states) such as –
- Experienced meaningfulness – When employees experience a sense of accomplishment in their work, it leads to feelings of purpose and fulfillment.
- Experienced responsibility for outcomes – By applying the job characteristics model and allowing personnel to have self-determination over their duties, employees feel empowered. When they accomplish these tasks effectively, it creates a boost in morale and satisfaction.
- Knowledge of the actual results – In some companies, employees may find it difficult to understand the impact of their hard work. To ensure that personnel can appreciate how they are helping to achieve organizational goals, precise task definitions and regular feedback need to be provided. This will help them realize just how vital their contributions are for success!
The JCM outlines the following work outcomes –
- Internal work motivation – Employees who experience job optimization through the job characteristics model gain a sense of responsibility for their work and deeper meaning in it, which leads to an elevation in internal motivation.
- Job satisfaction – When employees experience autonomy, and valuable and timely feedback, as well as acknowledge the importance of their work – this pushes them to achieve satisfaction. This then leads to improved performance overall.
- Work performance – This was one of the motivating factors that ultimately led to the development of the job characteristics model. Organizational psychologists believed they could improve performance by carefully utilizing these tools, and this theory has been proven true – when jobs are evaluated and modified in each category, it often results in increased productivity.
- Low absenteeism rate and turnover – Satisfied, involved employees are more likely to attend work faithfully and less prone to resignation.
- Quality and quantity of work – Utilizing this model can result in not only more efficient and better quality work but also a higher level of worker satisfaction. It’s an advantage for both employees and managers as it produces beneficial outcomes on all fronts.
Job Characteristics Model Moderators
Even Hackman and Oldham acknowledged that the Job Characteristics Model may not be comprehensive or applicable to everyone. Different people could have different perspectives about a job which is assumed to possess an encouraging capability.
The boundary between performance characteristics and mental states is bridged by innate attributes known as moderators. These moderators guarantee that the space between psychological conditions and operational features can be connected –
1) Knowledge & Skill
The moderator of knowledge and skill asserts that an employee with aptitude, discernment, and proficiencies is more likely to experience contentedness within the workspace. Additionally, if an employee doubts their own abilities and believes that they don’t have the necessary skills or knowledge to fulfill this role, feelings of dissatisfaction will replace enthusiasm and motivation.
2) Growth Needs Strength
‘Growth needs strength’ is a phrase that illustrates the extent of an employee’s aspiration to grow and thrive. An individual with a strong need for development will likely make faster progress when presented with new opportunities, eagerly rising up to meet any challenge along their path toward growth.
3) Context Satisfaction
Context and working conditions can impede access to the three psychological states, acting as a third moderating factor. When the context surrounding a job is satisfactory, concerning matters such as management, wage, benefits, and job security, employees will experience greater positivity that aids in achieving their desired psychological states.
Benefits of the Job Characteristics Model
The Job Characteristic Model (JCM) is a highly beneficial tool for professionals, providing an efficient template on how to structure roles through five core characteristics to analyze and optimize human performance. Studies have evidenced the significance of job design variables that are integrated into JCM (Parker et al., 2017), including but not limited to: –
- Job characteristics
- Feedback design
- Complexity
- Job attitudes
- Skill utilization
- Variety, etc
Moreover, the JCM attributes are associated with job analysis and can be employed when creating jobs to aid in recruitment and employee training. When it comes to analyzing an employee’s performance, JCM helps in understanding his or her performance quite effectively. The Job Characteristic Model provides detailed and valuable knowledge on employee inspiration, job contentment, and morale.
Limitations of the Job Characteristics Model
Unfortunately, the JCM is constrained by a lack of evidence to support some of its core theoretical relationships.
As the JCM was developed in the 1980s, it does not take into account today’s modern workplace which focuses on core competencies applicable across different roles. Back then, job design perfectly aligned with fixed roles within organizations; however, that is no longer applicable to a large extent due to changes in our current work environment.
Conclusion!
Enhancing job performance is a multi-layered procedure that can be achieved through the Job Characteristics Model. This model reveals ways to not just improve individual accomplishments, but also improve organizational behavior and success as well.
With a firm grasp of the Job Characteristics theory, managers can single out which job characteristics are most effective in motivating employees to peak performance.
Liked this post? Check out the complete series on Human resources
